Posts Tagged ‘child marriage’

I recently learned about “The Girl Effect” through a CNN article which exposed the power young girls have to break the cycle of poverty.

The Girl Effect is a movement driven by girl champions around the globe. The Nike Foundation created the Girl Effect with critical financial and intellectual contributions by the NoVo Foundation and Nike Inc. and in collaboration with key partners such as the United Nations Foundation and the Coalition for Adolescent Girls.

Other girl champions include the International Center for Research on Women, the Population CouncilCARE, the White Ribbon Alliance for Safe Motherhood, the Center for Global DevelopmentPlan, and the Girl Hub.

To date, little research has been done to understand how investing in young girls impacts economic growth and the health and well-being of communities; however, existing research suggests that the investing in young girls will prevent poverty before it starts.  According to The Girl Effect Data:

  • One in seven girls in developing countries marries before age 15, and 38 percent marry before age 18.
  • A young girl in the developing world who receives seven or more years of education will marry four years later and have 2.2 fewer children.
  • Worldwide, medical complications from pregnancy are the leading cause of death among girls ages 15 to 19.  Compared to women ages 20 to 24, girls ages 10 to 14 are five times more likely to die from child birth, and girls ages 15 to 19 are twice as likely.
  • 70% of the world’s 130 million out-of school youth are girls.
  • An extra year of primary school boosts a young girls’ eventual wages by 10 to 20 percent, while an extra year of secondary school equates to a 15 to 25 percent increase in eventual wages.

The World Bank recently released a working paper entitled, “The Girl Effect Dividend ,” which established just how powerful young girls are in today’s global society.  For example, in Brazil, if employment of young women was equal to employment of young men, Brazil would add $23 billion (US) to its annual GDP.  In Kenya, the report found that if all 1.6 million adolescent girls completed secondary school, and if all adolescent mothers were employed, the cumulative effect could have added $3.4 billion to Kenya’s gross income every year.  If young girls in Kenya, Tanzania, Senegal and Uganda had been able to complete primary school, “their additional output over their lifetimes would be equivalent to 20%, 18%,  14%,  and  13% of annual GDP”; and if their sisters had completed secondary school, they would have contributed “48%, 32%, 24%, and 34% (of annual GDP) more to their economies over their lifetimes, equivalent to an increase in annual GDP growth rates by  approximately  0.5% to 1% annually for the next 45 years.”

Girls are the invisible infrastructure of poverty. While her brothers go to school, ask 13-24 year girls in the developing world why they’re not in education and 33 percent say it’s because of household chores. Pregnancy is the leading cause of death among girls aged 15 to 19. There are slated to be 100 million child brides by 2020. Seventy-five percent of 15-24 year olds in sub-Saharan Africa living with HIV are girls.

When we get to girls in early adolescence – before they are married, pregnant, and HIV-positive – we invest in a solution for poverty, not a cure for its symptoms. Girls are the future mothers of every child born into poverty. Girls are integral to our food security, global health, peace and stability, economic growth – the whole gamut of investments, not just education.

In 2009, The Coalition for Adolescent Girls released “A Global Investment and Action Agenda,” which described: (i) why and how to put girls at the center of development; (ii) how the health of economies and families depends on protecting the rights of and fostering opportunities for today’s girls; and (iii) how far girls in many developing countries have come—but how far we remain from a world in which girls’ rights are respected.  Specifically, the report made the following key findings:

           Girls Matter

The well-being of girls matters first and foremost because girls are individuals with inalienable rights, but also because the well-being of young girls is vital to a thriving society.  The current global household economy depends largely on the unpaid/invisible contributions of women (e.g., carrying water, tending to crops or livestock, caring for children, and other household chores); as technological advancements influence global infrastructure and development, women will see reduced labor and agriculture demands, leaving more time for educational, governance, and political pursuits.  “The health and educational achievement of future generations is directly related to the physical and intellectual condition of today’s girls and young women, who will bear and prepare the children of the next decade.”

 We Are Failing Our Young Girls

Generally, girls in developing countries have less education, experience decreased overall health, have fewer rights that their male counterparts, and face “systematic disadvantages over a wide range of welfare indicators, including health, education, nutrition, labor force participation, and the burden of household tasks.”  Moreover, many young girls are forced to marry and give birth at a very young age, making them more susceptible to HIV infection, sexual and physical violence, and early death (during pregnancy).

           Governments Must Take Action

“National and local governments have primary responsibility to protect, promote, and fulfill the rights of all citizens.”  In order to improve prospects for young girls, local and national governments must ensure:

Equal Protection and Equal Access

Governments must enforce existing laws and policies (both national and local) which seek to protect young women and girls, and identify and eliminate laws and policies that inherently discriminate against young women and girls.  The birth of every girl and boy should be recorded, and every child should be issued a birth certificate.  Legal (or defacto) restrictions which prevent pregnant, married, and/or young mothers from enrolling in school must be eliminated, as well as limits on access to reproductive health information.

Additionally, women and young girls must have equal access to all social programs, including health services, all levels of education, youth services, recreational activities, and peer-to-peer programs.  Data should be collected to determine who is presently benefiting from such services, and benchmarks should be set to ensure that underrepresented groups obtain greater access.

Employment and Public Works Opportunities for Women

In most countries, governments provide unskilled manual laborers with short-term employment opportunities (often in construction, maintenance, irrigation infrastructure, reforestation, and soil conservation), and sometimes even long term-employment.  Governments must actively seek to develop similar initiatives for female workers in order to provide equal hiring and pay opportunities.

Community Organizations and Private Donors Must Get Involved

The report suggests that official and private donors, as well as multilateral agencies of the U.N., should not only support the aforementioned initiatives, but also focus on developing HIV/AIDS programs for girls, and support post-primary education programs.

HIV/AIDS Programs Must Focus on Prevention and Young Girls

Young women and girls are increasingly affected by HIV/AIDS, yet most HIV/AIDS programs do not focus on girls or prevention.  International HIV/AIDS prevention programs must develop and implement strategies to reduce the new infection rate amongst young women and girls, and measure the success of these strategies against this specific infection rate.

Encourage and Support Post-Primary Education

Most education initiatives focus on primary education, however, “this approach has been insufficient both for the girls themselves and for attaining the social benefits of education.  Research has shown that parents often discourage girls who are at or near puberty to drop out of school in order to preserve their reputation and marriage prospects; and therefore, donors must focus their initiatives on: (i) improving the quality of primary and secondary education; (ii) encouraging secondary education to all young girls; (iii) investing in girls who are at or near puberty and are at the greatest risk of dropping out; and (iv) removing the social barriers that prevent young girls from transitioning from primary to secondary education.

Private Corporations Must Take Action

Since agriculture and informal sectors dominate the economic activities of developing countries, the opportunities for private and multinational corporations to influence economic opportunities for women is limited; however, corporations (both private and multinational) have a social responsibility to invest in young girls and to contribute to their well-being.  Private corporations must act responsibly, and implement fair hiring and pay policies to ensure that individuals are hired without regard to gender, marital status, or pregnancy, and also that women are paid equally and receive the same employment benefits.  Since large multinational corporations have the resources and ability to invest in local schools, they should provide scholarships, build schools, invest in distance learning technologies, and enhance teacher training opportunities.  Additionally, private employers should provide young female employees with resources and services to build their personal assets.  For example, an employer could institute a private onsite savings account for young women who otherwise could not open a bank account without the permission of a male family member.

Civil Society Organizations Must Get Involved

Advocate For Changes in Social Attitudes and Norms

Civil society organizations can dramatically influence social attitudes and social norms simply by implementing community sensitivity and social marketing campaigns.  At the same time, these organizations must advocate for changes in laws and policies to reflect the changing social attitudes and norms.

Develop Informal Education Opportunities & Create Safe Places for Girls

The majority of out-of-school girls come from “socially excluded populations,” and civil organizations are the most effective tool for reaching these girls.  These organizations should seek to implement school-to-work programs which provide incentives to private sector business to work with schools to transition female graduates into the workforce.  Private employers should also invest in professional training centers where young women can get involved in apprenticeships and skill building courses, as well as enroll in financial literacy and life skills programs.  Young women must also have access to mentors and supportive social networks in order to thrive.  Civil society organizations should look to establish safe places where girls can congregate, take educational classes (HIV/AIDS training, financial literacy, sexual violence, etc.), and support one another.

Girls are unique change agents. Igniting her potential and transforming her world starts a ripple effect of change – for herself, her family, and her community… Investing in girls is smart economics.”

 

It’s estimated that 100 to 140 million women and girls worldwide have undergone some form of FGM, and at least 40% of Kurdish girls and women have experienced FGM.  Young girls frequently undergo a form of FGM called genital excision, where the clitoris is removed as a precursor to marriage. A UN Study explained that: “FGM is seen as a protection of virginity, a beautification process, and in a number of cultures is regarded as an essential precondition of marriage.”  Despite increasing international efforts to eradicate the practice, it’s estimated that three million girls each year are at risk of undergoing the procedure.

On June 21, 2011, the Kurdistan parliament passed the Family Violence Bill which criminalizes FGM, and also criminalizes forced and child marriages, verbal, physical, and psychological abuse of girls and women, child abuse, and child labor.   Although the bill has yet to be ratified by the president of the Kurdistan Regional Government, human rights leaders worldwide have called the bill a positive step toward eradicating FGM.

Nadya Khalife, Middle East women’s rights researcher at Human Rights Watch recently stated: “[b]y passing this law, the Kurdistan regional government has shown its resolve to end female genital mutilation and to protect the rights of women and girls…but the government needs a long-term strategy to deal with this harmful practice because criminalizing it is not enough….Once the ban is in effect, government agencies should widely disseminate information on the new law making sure it reaches women and girls at risk of FGM…Everyone should now know that the mutilation of girls is prohibited.”

The new law makes it easier for alleged victims to press charges, establishes special family courts for family violence cases, establishes a framework for police and courts to both issue and enforce restraining orders to protect abuse victims, and sets forth penalties for these crimes (including prison sentences).  Specifically, Article six contains four separate provisions regarding FGM, both criminalizing the practice and establishing punishments for anyone who “instigate[s], assist[s], or carr[ies] out the procedure (including medical professionals and midwives). Punishments for violating the new law include prison terms ranging from six months to three years, as well as fines of up to 10 million dinars ($8,500).

In June 2010, Human Rights Watch issued a report, “They Took Me and Told Me Nothing: Female Genital Mutilation in Iraqi Kurdistan,” “which urged the Kurdistan Regional Government and the Kurdistan parliament to take a series of steps to end the practice, including enacting laws banning it.”

The Report stated that while legislation is a key component to eradicating FGM, the government must also implement necessary victims’ services, such as health care, and social and psychological support.  HRW also urged the regional government to partner with community midwives (who most often perform the procedure) to institute public awareness campaigns condemning the practice. Finally, the Report called upon the regional government to “develop a comprehensive legal and policy framework with relevant ministries and civil society organizations aimed at eradicating the practice.”

Shortly after the Report was released, The High Committee for Issuing Fatwas at the Kurdistan Islamic Scholars Union (the highest Muslim religious authority in Iraqi Kurdistan on religious pronouncements and rulings) issued a fatwa which stated that FGM predates Islam and is not required by the Islamic religion.  Although the fatwa did not expressly ban or condemn the practice, it did acknowledge the negative health consequences of FGM, and encouraged parents to avoid having the procedure performed on their daughters.

Not long after the HRW Report was published, a Kurdistan Health Ministry survey (of 5,000 women and girls) found that 41% had undergone the procedure, and further that FGM is more prevalent in some regions outside of Kurdistan.

HRW appropriately stated: “[f]emale genital mutilation violates the rights of women to life, health and bodily integrity, non-discrimination and the right not to be subjected to cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment. In addition, since the practice predominantly affects girls under 18, it also violates children’s rights to health, life, physical integrity, and non-discrimination.”

 

Sources:

http://www.hrw.org/news/2011/07/25/iraqi-kurdistan-law-banning-fgm-positive-step

http://www.crin.org/violence/search/closeup.asp?infoid=24431

http://www.stopfgmkurdistan.org/study_fgm_iraqi_kurdistan_en.pdf

The Facts

100 Million: The number of girls worldwide who will be married before the age of 18 (in the next decade).

51 Million: The number of girls (ages 15 – 19) presently married worldwide.

82%, 75%, 63%, 57%, and 50%:  The percentage of girls in Niger, Bangladesh, Nepal, India, and Uganda who marry before age 18.

39%: The percentage of girls in the Amhara region of Ethiopia who marry before age 15.

66%: The percentage of girls among Nigeria’s poorest 20% who will marry before age 15.

12%: The percentage of girls among Nigeria’s richest 20% who will marry before age 15.

Driven by, and Connected to Poverty

Child marriage is highly prevalent in two of the world’s most impoverished areas, sub-Saharan Africa and parts of South Asia.  In Bangladesh, Mali, Mozambique, and Niger, more than 75% of the population lives on less than $2.00 per day, and more than half of the young girls are married before age 18 (91% of Mali’s population lives on less than $2.00 per day).  A country’s GDP is also intimately connected to the incidence of child marriage.  Chad has a GDP of $1600 per capita, and 71% of young girls are married; contrast that with South Africa which has a GDP of $11,100 per capita and only 8% of the young girls are married.  Not surprisingly, household economic status is a key factor in childhood marriage, as children from poorer families are much more likely to be married at a young age than children from wealthy families.  According to the International Center for Research on Women (ICRW), young girls from poorer families are twice as likely to marry before age 18 than children from wealthier families.  Not only is the young girl often viewed as a financial burden, but in South Asia and sub-Saharan Africa, marriage also involves the exchange of wealth between families in the form of a dowry and/or a bride price, providing greater financial incentives for child marriage.

Violence & Abuse

A 2004 study conducted by the ICRW and its partners on young people in the states of Bihar and Jharkhand, India revealed that girls who were married before 18-years of age were twice as likely to report marital abuse (beatings, slapping, or threats), and three times as likely to report being forced to have sex without their consent (in the most recent 6 months) than girls who married later.  The survey also found that girls who married before age 18 consistently reported having more difficulty approaching and talking with their husbands about contraception, as well as when to have children and how many children to have.

Several other studies have confirmed the link between child marriage and domestic violence.  In Peru for example, a study found that child marriage increases the likelihood of domestic abuse.  In Kenya, 36% of girls married before age 18 believe that a husband is justified in beating his wife; whereas only 20% of married women hold such belief.  Young brides typically have less “bargaining power” (as compared to married women) as a result of their young age and lack of education, which also increases the likelihood of spousal abuse.

Health Impacts

Child marriage results in child sexual activity, and by extension, early child bearing.  Adolescent female bodies are not sufficiently developed or prepared for child birth, making young girls much more susceptible to complications (including death) during childbirth.  Compared to women in their 20s, girls under 15 years of age are five times more likely to die during childbirth.  In fact, pregnancy is the leading cause of death worldwide for young women age 15 to 19.  Adolescent childbirth is also dangerous for the infant.  Because young mothers are not physically suited for childbirth, infants born to young mothers are much more likely to suffer serious complications and/or die as compared to infants born to mothers in their 20s.

The incidence of HIV/AIDS is also much higher in married sexually active adolescents as compared to unmarried sexually active adolescents.  Though more research is needed to understand the connection between marriage and HIV/AIDS, current research suggests that married adolescents are more susceptible to HIV/AIDS because they have little to no option to change their sexual behavior in response to knowledge about HIV/AIDS.  For example, a study of young girls in Kenya and Zambia reported that unmarried adolescents were much more likely to change their sexual behavior (including abstaining from having sex) after learning about HIV/AIDS; whereas married adolescents did not have the option to abstain from sex.

Education as a Deterrent

According to an ICRW study of 18 of 20 countries with the highest incidence of child marriage, a young girl’s level of education is the highest predictor of the age she will marry.  In all regions of the developing world, educated girls are less likely to marry as children.  Moreover, girls who receive secondary schooling are six times less likely to marry before the age of 18 than girls with little to no education.  For economic reasons, many girls do not have the opportunity to attend school or are pulled from schools in order to get married.  Once married, a young girl’s access to both formal and informal education is severely limited because of family burdens, as well as financial concerns and societal norms.

- In Nicaragua, 45% of girls with no education are married before the age of 18, compared to just 28% of girls with a primary education, 16% of girls with secondary education, and only 5% of girls with higher education.

- In Mozambique, 60% of girls with no education are married before the age 18, compared to just 10% of girls with secondary schooling and 1% of girls with higher education.

- In Senegal, 41% of young girls with no education are married, but only 14% of girls with a primary education marry as children.

These statistics and numerous studies confirm that educating adolescent girls is a crucial component of increasing the age of marriage in developing countries.

(Source: http://www.icrw.org/publications/child-marriage-factsheets)